Blueberry Yogurt Taste Test

May 21, 2013


Have you ever found yourself at the grocery store in the yogurt isle looking at all the choices that are available and wondering what tastes best? We certainly have! Joe and I eat a lot of Greek yogurt since it’s packed with protein and makes a great breakfast or snack. Sometimes I even eat a Greek yogurt in place of dessert during the week. At over $1 per yogurt, I want the yogurt I buy to taste great, not just okay.

While I prefer plain yogurt, Joe is a huge fan of all things blueberry. So on Saturday we decided to sit down with six different yogurts for a little taste test. We tasted them all so you don’t have to!

Here’s how we put together our taste test:
-The yogurts we selected were based on what was readily available at our local Super Target. I know there are a couple other widely available blueberry Greek yogurts that were not included, which is only because our Target only had these varieties in stock.
-A few of the yogurts aren’t “Greek” yogurts (Noosa and Siggis) but were thick strained yogurts, so we included them in the test.
-We wrote down our thoughts independently and came to the following conclusions…


Chobani 0% Blueberry Greek Yogurt
Flavor Notes:
We have eaten a lot of Chobani over the past couple years, but I was curious to see how it stacked up in comparison with all the other yogurts we tried. Ultimately, it was a very tight race between Chobani and Liberté, with Chobani edging out Liberté by a nose. What won us over was the smooth, creamy consistency and the fact that despite being non-fat, it wasn’t pasty at all, unlike some of the other yogurts we tried. Additionally, we really loved the real blueberries in the fruit mixture. Our only complaint was that we wished it was a little less sweet.

Liberté Non-Fat Blueberry Greek Yogurt
Flavor Notes:
This yogurt was new-ish to both of us. I’ve had the plain variety a few times over the past month, but we had never tried the flavored varieties, like this blueberry. Coming in second place, Liberté won us over by having the best true blueberry flavor out of the bunch with a smooth, creamy consistency and real blueberries in the fruit mixture. Joe wished it was a bit thicker, but the sweetness level was perfectly pleasant. In fact, Joe thought that combining the Chobani and Liberté 50/50 created his perfect version of blueberry Greek yogurt.

Fage Fruyo 0% Blueberry Greek Yogurt
Flavor Notes:
This was the first time I’ve seen the Fruyo variety of Chobani in stores. I’m a big fan of the plain 2% Fage, so I had high expectations of this Fruyo. Unlike the traditional flavored Fage, which comes with a side car of fruit mixture, this variety has the fruit blended into the yogurt. My first impression was how sweet the yogurt tasted, a little too sweet for both of us, but we couldn’t get over the great texture. It was ultra creamy and had zero pasty taste. We also loved the blueberry flavor. If it had been less sweet I think it may have been the winner.

OTHERSNoosa Australian Style Blueberry Yogurt
Flavor Notes:
Neither of us had ever tried Noosa before, but I had heard good things about this Australian-style yogurt. One container (8 oz) is considered two servings, and each 4 oz serving has 150 calories, meaning it’s much more decadent than the other yogurts in the bunch. After tasting it, we can totally see why! Joe and I both agreed that we loved this yogurt, but it would probably make a better healthy dessert rather than a breakfast yogurt. We loved the blueberries and creamy, rich texture. It just seemed a little indulgent for everyday.

Trader Joe’s 0% Blueberry Greek Yogurt
Flavor Notes:
We shop at Trader Joe’s every week, so many times Joe ends up getting Trader Joe’s blueberry Greek yogurt to save us from making another trip somewhere else just for Greek yogurt. However, after this taste test, I’m thinking we might need to reconsider our strategy! This is one case where Trader Joe’s does not deliver. The yogurt was tart, pasty and left our mouths feeling dry. Additionally, it didn’t deliver on blueberry flavor.

Siggis 0% Blueberry Yogurt
Flavor Notes:
I’m not exactly sure what makes something “Icelandic-style” like Siggis claims to be, but we were not impressed with this yogurt. I am a fan of many different types of yogurts, but you couldn’t pay me to eat a whole container of this stuff. Both Joe and I felt like it was absurdly tart, almost as if it contained an entire lemon. The blueberry flavor was nonexistent and it left us with a sour taste in our mouths. Definitely something to skip!

What are your favorite brands of yogurt? In your opinion, did we get it right with our taste test?


You Might Also Like


  • Reply Kara Knaack May 21, 2013 at 7:26 pm

    Thanks for the breakdown – the only other thing I would have liked to have seen was prices too!

  • Reply Cindy Germann May 21, 2013 at 8:16 pm

    What a fun idea!! It’s amazing how the same “thing” can be so different between brands. I would love some greek yogurt with granola and berries right now. YUM.

  • Reply Sarah Jane May 21, 2013 at 8:48 pm

    I used to only eat Chobani, but I have now been eating Oikos greek yogurt and I think that it is my favorite, and usually a little cheaper too, a win-win

  • Reply Christine May 22, 2013 at 12:20 am

    I’ve tried oikos, fage, and chobani, and I think the best tasting is actually homemade mixed with frozen blueberries and sugar or honey. Homemade is also sooooo much cheaper, and I like that I can control the creaminess/thickness to get it exactly how I want it. With all the greek yogurt you guys eat, you should look into making your own or buying a yogurt maker to see if you like it any better! 🙂

  • Reply Sarah Dillard May 22, 2013 at 12:31 pm

    I am a huge yogurt fan– I eat a lot of it and it started getting expensive so I started making it myself. It is easy and much less expensive and I have total control of what goes into it. Making the yogurt a thicker greek style is easy– I just drain the yogurt with a melita single cup coffee filter for a few hours. Once you get in the routine of doing this it really is no trouble at all!

  • Reply Laura Wifler May 22, 2013 at 9:22 pm

    Great idea Madison – I always like trying the new brands, and this
    eliminates some for me! 🙂 Lately, I’ve been purchasing the Fage brand
    in bulk, then adding in preserves from Trader Joes – I’m crazy about
    raspberry, but I’m sure blueberry would be just as good. I like it
    because it saves TONS of money!

  • Reply Anne McCormick May 23, 2013 at 3:08 pm

    Thanks for doing all the legwork for us! I love the blueberry yogurt from Chobani.

  • Reply Emily May 26, 2013 at 10:49 pm

    I used to be faithful to Chobani but after eating Oikos one time I switched over because the texture is sooo creamy. Thanks for sharing your taste test!

  • Reply Emily Rasmussen May 31, 2013 at 1:40 pm

    This post is so great; it makes me think of wine tasting but Greek Yogurt 😀 hehe!

    • Reply Madison Mayberry May 31, 2013 at 1:55 pm

      Haha I love that! 🙂 Am I going to see you this weekend?!

    Leave a Reply

    Espresso & Cream Behind the Scenes

    Stay in touch and sign up for the Espresso & Cream mailing list! This is where I share behind-the-scenes sneak peeks into what I'm loving, cooking, eating, wearing and more. 

    You have Successfully Subscribed!